Technical Resources

Forever Steel Manufacturing Co., Ltd
steel plate selection,A516 Gr 70,A572 Gr 50,S355J2,AH36,EN 10164,steel plate RFQ

Latest news list

Steel Plate Selection Guide: A516 Gr 70 vs A572 Gr 50 vs S355J2 vs AH36

Date: 2026-11-10Author:Chuck Yu

Quick answer

Choose steel plate by the governing specification first, then confirm grade, thickness, delivery condition, tests and certificate on the same order line. Four grades that buyers often treat as interchangeable have different acceptance bases: A516 Gr 70 (pressure vessel; 485–620 MPa tensile, 260 MPa minimum yield), A572 Gr 50 (structural; 345 MPa minimum yield, 450 MPa minimum tensile), S355J2 (EN 10025-2; 355 MPa yield up to 16 mm but 345 MPa at 30 mm, 27 J at −20 °C) and AH36/DH36/EH36 (hull plate; 355 MPa minimum yield, 490–620 MPa tensile, Charpy at 0, −20 and −40 °C). A higher yield figure does not make a structural plate a substitute for pressure vessel plate; the vessel design basis and the responsible engineer decide.

An RFQ line reading “30 mm high-strength plate” leaves the supplier to guess. The sections below show which fields change the price, the delivery time and the acceptance outcome.

1. A516 Gr 70, A572 Gr 50, S355J2 and AH36: strength and impact compared

They differ more in what the standard guarantees than in strength. The table lists minimum values from the specification texts or datasheets cited in the references.

Grade

Governing specification

Typical component

Min. yield

Tensile strength

Impact in the grade definition

A516 Gr 70

ASTM A516/A516M

Pressure vessel shell, head

260 MPa (38 ksi)

485–620 MPa (70–90 ksi); elongation 21% in 50 mm, 17% in 200 mm

Ordered separately; plate ≤40 mm ordered with notch-toughness tests is normalized unless the purchaser specifies otherwise (§5.3)

A572 Gr 50

ASTM A572/A572M

Structural frames, connections

345 MPa (50 ksi)

≥450 MPa (65 ksi); elongation 21% in 50 mm, 18% in 200 mm

State on the order if required

S355J2

EN 10025-2

Structural steelwork

355 MPa ≤16 mm; 345 MPa >16–40 mm; 335 MPa >40–63 mm

470–630 MPa

27 J at −20 °C (the “J2” designation)

AH36 / DH36 / EH36

Classification society rules (e.g. ABS, IACS)

Hull, deck, ship structure

≥355 MPa

490–620 MPa

Charpy test at 0 °C (AH36), −20 °C (DH36), −40 °C (EH36); energy values per the class rules

 

Two points save RFQ rework. First, “S355” is not one yield value: at 30 mm the S355J2 minimum is 345 MPa, not 355 MPa, so a design calculated with 355 MPa needs a thickness check. Second, A516 Gr 70 has the lowest yield in the table, yet it is the grade the vessel specification names. Lower yield is not a defect; pressure design uses the allowable stresses and toughness route written into the vessel code.

2. Plate families by component and governing document

Start from the component, because the document that owns the grade decision differs by application.

steel plate selection,A516 Gr 70,A572 Gr 50,S355J2,AH36,EN 10164,steel plate RFQ 

Figure 1. Five steel plate applications and representative fabricated components.

Component

Plate family and reference

Document that owns the grade

Pressure vessel shell, head

Pressure vessel plate: ASTM A516/A516M, or the ASME SA-516 designation where the design specifies it

Vessel material specification or requisition

Frame, connection, load-bearing part

Structural plate: ASTM A572, or a grade and subgrade of EN 10025

Structural drawing and design code

Hull, deck, ship member

Shipbuilding plate: AH36, DH36, EH36 under the adopted class rules

Class-approved material list

Offshore platform or marine structure

Offshore plateper the project material specification

Project specification and class rules

Feedstock for welded line pipe

Line-pipe plateper the pipe mill’s approved specification; API Spec 5L applies to the finished pipe

Pipe mill purchase specification

3. A516 Gr 70 delivery condition: as-rolled or normalized

It depends on thickness and on whether notch-toughness tests are required. A516/A516M sets three rules: plate up to 40 mm (1.50 in.) is normally supplied as-rolled but may be ordered normalized, stress relieved or both; plate over 40 mm shall be normalized; and plate up to 40 mm ordered with notch-toughness testing is normalized unless the purchaser specifies otherwise. Faster-than-air cooling for toughness is allowed only with purchaser approval, and the plate is then tempered at 595–705 °C (1100–1300 °F).

Ordered A516 plate

Delivery condition per A516/A516M

What to write on the order

≤40 mm, no toughness test

Normally as-rolled; normalizing optional

Condition: as-rolled or normalized, stated explicitly

≤40 mm, with notch-toughness test

Normalized unless the purchaser specifies otherwise

Normalized; test temperature, values, orientation, sampling

>40 mm

Normalizing required

Normalized, plus any toughness requirement from the vessel specification

 

Where the plate will be hot formed or receive post-weld heat treatment, give the fabricator the proposed plate condition and let the responsible engineer review it before any alternate route is accepted.

4. Steel plate weight: 30 mm example and quote weight basis

Carbon steel plate weighs about 7.85 kg per square metre for each millimetre of thickness, so a 30 mm plate is 235.5 kg/m². The example below is arithmetic from that density; actual mill weight varies with thickness tolerance.

Item

Calculation

Result

Unit weight at 30 mm

7.85 kg/m² per mm × 30 mm

235.5 kg/m²

Area of one 2,000 × 6,000 mm plate

2.0 m × 6.0 m

12.0 m²

Weight of one plate

12.0 m² × 235.5 kg/m²

2,826 kg

Weight of four plates

4 × 2,826 kg

11,304 kg

 

Ask every bidder to state whether the price is per tonne of theoretical weight or of actual weighed weight, and how cutting yield is treated for cut-to-size orders. Two quotes with the same price per tonne are not equal if one bills theoretical weight and the other bills weighed weight.

5. Charpy, ultrasonic and Z-direction tests: what each one proves

They answer different questions, so one report does not replace another. A plate UT report shows internal discontinuities; a through-thickness tensile test shows ductility in the thickness direction.

steel plate selection,A516 Gr 70,A572 Gr 50,S355J2,AH36,EN 10164,steel plate RFQ

Figure 2. Charpy impact, straight-beam UT and through-thickness tensile tests (conceptual).

Requirement

What it shows

Write on the order

Charpy V-notch (CVN)

Energy absorbed at a stated temperature

Temperature, required values, orientation, sampling basis

Straight-beam UT

Internal discontinuities such as laminations

UT standard (e.g. ASTM A578), acceptance level, scanning coverage, edge zones

Through-thickness tensile

Reduction of area in the thickness direction

EN 10164 class Z15, Z25 or Z35, or the equivalent specification

 

EN 10164 defines the Z classes by reduction of area, measured as the mean of three specimens and the lowest single result:

Class

Minimum mean of three tests

Minimum individual value

Z15

15%

10%

Z25

25%

15%

Z35

35%

25%

 

Only reduction of area is measured, not tensile strength. For plate thicker than 20 mm the specimens can be cut entirely from the plate; thinner plate needs welded extension pieces. Ask for a Z class when the design places tensile load through the thickness at a welded joint, and write the class on the order line, not only in the drawing notes.

For plate that becomes LSAW pipe, see Plate Ultrasonic Testing for LSAW Pipe for scope and edge-zone requirements.

6. AH36, DH36 and EH36: the Charpy temperature sets the grade

The strength level is the same; the grade letter sets the Charpy test temperature. AH36, DH36 and EH36 share a minimum yield of 355 MPa and a tensile range of 490–620 MPa, and are tested at 0 °C, −20 °C and −40 °C respectively.

Grade

Min. yield

Tensile

Charpy test temperature

AH36

355 MPa

490–620 MPa

0 °C

DH36

355 MPa

490–620 MPa

−20 °C

EH36

355 MPa

490–620 MPa

−40 °C

 

On a quote, confirm the class society, the exact grade, thickness, the mill’s approval scope for that society, and the inspection certificate. Take Charpy energy values from the class rules adopted for the vessel, not from a trading-company datasheet.

7. Worked RFQ example: four A516 Gr 70 plates, 30 × 2,000 × 6,000 mm

Assume the vessel requisition specifies ASME SA-516 Grade 70, normalized, with impact and UT records to named project clauses. The total is 11,304 kg (section 4). The three bid responses below look similar on price but sit at different stages of acceptance.

Bid response

What it establishes

Buyer action

SA-516 Gr 70, normalized; names the impact and UT clauses; reports linked to plate numbers

Grade, condition and test scope all addressed

Review the sample documentation, then release

“A516 Gr 70, 30 mm”; condition and tests not stated

Related designation and thickness only

Ask for the exact designation on the certificate, the delivery condition and written test confirmation before comparing price

Structural plate of similar nominal strength, available sooner

A different product specification

Log as an item-level deviation and send to the design authority

 

Keep these three statuses separate in the comparison sheet so an unresolved material choice does not become a purchasing assumption.

Mill test certificate example for checking the ordered grade

The following fields are transcribed from an ASTM A516/A516M-2017 certificate for 5 mm Grade 60 plate. The grade on this record differs from the Grade 70 specified in the example above.

Certificate field

Selected information

Material and thickness

ASTM A516 Grade 60, 5 mm nominal thickness. The certificate identifies the grade as GR60+S5.

Reported tensile results

Transverse tensile test. Yield strength 435 MPa, tensile strength 552 MPa, elongation 33.0%.

Reported Charpy results

Longitudinal impact specimens, 5.00 mm thick, at −46 °C. Individual values 158, 166 and 165 J. Reported average 163 J.

Purchase review

Compare the grade on the certificate with the purchase order before reviewing impact values or any other test results.

steel plate selection,A516 Gr 70,A572 Gr 50,S355J2,AH36,EN 10164,steel plate RFQ

Article example using the Forever Steel plate template, populated with selected tensile, chemistry and impact results for the 5 mm A516 Grade 60 plate.

An impact result at the specified temperature does not establish the ordered grade. For the Grade 70 requisition above, confirm the correct material designation and review the required UT record separately.

8. Steel plate RFQ checklist

·Application and authority:component, drawing or requisition revision, governing design code, class society if any.

·Material:specification and edition, grade or subgrade, delivery condition, permitted alternatives.

·Dimensions and weight:thickness × width × length, quantity, tolerance basis, edge condition, full plate or cut parts, theoretical or actual weight billing.

·Tests and records:CVN, UT or Z class with standard and acceptance level, certificate type, marking and traceability.

·Quote response:deviations, proposed mill and documentation scope per order line; packing and delivery terms.

Steel plate FAQ

Can A572 Gr 50 replace A516 Gr 70 in a pressure vessel?

Not on yield strength alone. A572 Gr 50 has a higher minimum yield (345 MPa against 260 MPa), but the vessel material must be permitted by the design code and approved by the design authority, with the toughness and certificate basis the vessel specification requires. Treat any substitution as a recorded deviation.

Is A516 Gr 70 always normalized?

No. Under A516/A516M, plate up to 40 mm is normally as-rolled but may be ordered normalized; plate over 40 mm must be normalized. State the condition on the order.

What is the yield strength of S355J2 at 30 mm?

345 MPa minimum for thickness over 16 mm up to 40 mm under EN 10025-2. The 355 MPa value applies up to 16 mm.

What do Z15, Z25 and Z35 mean?

They are EN 10164 through-thickness classes by minimum reduction of area: 15%, 25% and 35% mean of three tests, with individual minimums of 10%, 15% and 25%.

What is the difference between AH36, DH36 and EH36?

Same minimum yield (355 MPa) and tensile range (490–620 MPa); the Charpy test temperature is 0 °C, −20 °C and −40 °C respectively.

Is a plate described as API 5L X65 enough to release an LSAW pipe order?

No. API Spec 5L covers finished line pipe. For LSAW, use the pipe mill’s approved plate specification and verify final pipe grade, PSL and pipe tests against the line-pipe requisition.

Conclusion

Release a plate inquiry with the application, grade, delivery condition, dimensions, weight basis and acceptance evidence on one order line or linked requisition. If a quote leaves any of those open, clarify it before comparing prices. Send your plate schedule and inspection requirements to Forever Steel for a quotation review, or browse the plate range by application.

· Product pages: Pressure Vessel Plates ·ASTM Structural Steel Plate ·Shipbuilding Plates ·Marine & Offshore Plates ·Pipeline Steel Plates

Related Articles

· Plate Ultrasonic Testing for LSAW Pipe

· How to Read a Steel Pipe MTC: Tests and Heat Traceability

· Charpy Impact Test for Steel Pipe: Procurement and MTC Guide

References and sources

1. ASTM A516/A516M-17, Pressure Vessel Plates, Carbon Steel (heat treatment §5, Table 2)

2. Murray Plate, Boilerplate ASTM A516 Gr 60 & 70 datasheet (485–620 MPa tensile, 260 MPa yield)

3. AA Steel, ASTM A572 (Gr 50: 50 ksi yield, 65 ksi tensile)

4. British Steel, S355J2 data sheet (EN 10025-2)

5. EN 10164:2018 preview, Table 1 quality classes

6. SAKY Steel, AH36 vs DH36 vs EH36 (yield, tensile and test temperatures; mill source, verify against class rules)

7. API, scope of API Specification 5L for finished line pipe.

Find what you need ?
close